Chapter 199: Cyprian

Amid the turbulence of the third century, a time of imperial hostility, ecclesiastical upheaval, and internal schism, Cyprian of Carthage rose as the commanding embodiment of episcopal authority and Catholic unity. Born into privilege yet shaped by renunciation, trained in eloquence yet tempered by martyrdom, he stands as the great bishop of his age: a man whose zeal for the Church’s unity matched his pastoral tenderness, and whose death sealed with blood the convictions he so ably defended in life.

Manuscripts, Editions, and Translations

The collected works of St. Cyprian (S. Cypriani Opera Omnia) reach their most critical form in the edition of W. Hartel (Vienna, 1868–1871, 3 vols. octavo, in the Corpus Scriptorum Ecclesiasticorum Latinorum), based on the painstaking collation of forty manuscripts. Earlier landmarks include the editio princeps by Sweynheym and Pannartz (Rome, 1471), a Venetian reprint of 1477, and Erasmus’ Basel edition of 1520—the first to employ critical method—frequently reissued thereafter. Paul Manutius (Rome, 1563), Morell (Paris, 1564), and Rigault (Paris, 1648) carried forward the work; Bishop John Fell’s Oxford edition of 1682, enriched by Bishop Pearson’s Annales Cyprianici, remains notable, as does the Benedictine edition (Paris, 1726) begun by Baluzius and completed by Prud. Maranus—lavishly produced, carefully revised, and politically tailored to Roman curial tastes. This was reprinted in Venice (1758) and Migne’s Patrologia Latina (vol. IV and part of vol. V). Gersdorf’s Leipzig edition (1838 ff.) in the Bibliotheca Patrum Latinarum offered a compact manual form. English readers know Cyprian through N. Marshall’s 1717 translation, the Oxford Library of the Fathers (1840), and R. G. Wallis’ rendering in the Ante-Nicene Library (Edinburgh, 1868; New York, 1885).

Biographical Sources

The earliest life, Vita Cypriani by his deacon Pontius, together with the Acta Proconsularia Martyrii Cypriani, appears in Ruinart’s Acta Martyrum and in many editions of Cyprian’s works. Pearson’s Annales Cyprianici (Oxford, 1682) brought chronological precision to the letters and corrected numerous earlier errors. Dodwell’s Dissertationes Cyprianicae Tres (Oxford, 1684; Amsterdam, 1700) further refined the historical framework. Notable later biographies include Gervaise’s Vie de St. Cyprien (Paris, 1717), Rettberg’s Cyprianus nach seinem Leben und Wirken (Göttingen, 1831), Poole’s Life and Times of Cyprian (Oxford, 1840), Blampignon’s Vie de Cyprien (Paris, 1861), Freppel’s ultramontane Saint Cyprien et l’Église d’Afrique au troisième siècle (Paris, 1865, 2nd ed. 1873), and Peters’ Der heilige Cyprian (Regensburg, 1877). Specialized studies abound, from B. Fechtrup’s two-volume Leben und Lehre (Münster, 1878) to Otto Ritschl’s Cyprian vom Karthago und die Verfassung der Kirche (Göttingen, 1885).

From Rhetorician to Bishop

Thascius Caecilius Cyprianus, bishop and martyr, was born in Carthage around the year 200 into a noble and wealthy pagan household. Pontius dismisses his pre-Christian years as unworthy of record compared with his later greatness, though Jerome notes his renown as a teacher of rhetoric. Possessed of refined literary culture, legal acumen, and administrative talent, Cyprian enjoyed worldly distinction and the moral compromises common to his milieu. Allegations of magical practice are unsupported, though in later life he shared Tertullian’s belief in visions and dreams.

A presbyter named Caecilius, resident in Cyprian’s household, became the instrument of his conversion—guiding him to Scripture, urging him toward Christ. After a long inner struggle, Cyprian embraced the faith, entered the catechumenate, sold his estates for the poor, vowed chastity, and was baptized in 245 or 246, taking his benefactor’s name in gratitude.

In a vivid account to a friend, he recalls the transformation: from the moral darkness of pagan luxury, where the thought of new birth seemed impossible, to the radiant certainty that followed baptism—when what had been arduous became easy, and divine light flooded the cleansed heart. Thereafter, he devoted himself in ascetic retreat to Scripture and the Fathers, above all Tertullian, whom he daily requested with the phrase, “Hand me the master!”

The Call to Episcopal Leadership

Only two years after baptism, the acclaim of the Carthaginian faithful swept Cyprian into the episcopate, despite his protest and despite ecclesiastical canons cautioning against elevating a neophyte (cf. 1 Tim. 3:6). His rapid rise sparked opposition, later crystallizing in the Novatian schism, yet—like the later elections of Ambrose and Augustine—it was vindicated by his fruitful ministry.

For a decade he governed Carthage’s church with energy, prudence, and fidelity amidst fierce persecution and internal discord. Under Valerian he endured exile, then trial, and finally the sentence of beheading. Accepting his fate with serene gratitude, he prayed, bound his own eyes, rewarded his executioner, and met death with heroic calm on September 14, 258. His burial was secret; memorial chapels soon arose at the places of his execution and grave. The Church of North Africa long commemorated his martyrdom, Augustine himself preaching five surviving sermons in his honor.

Character and Ecclesiastical Vision

If Origen was the preeminent scholar and Tertullian the most forceful writer, Cyprian was the consummate bishop of the third century—a natural leader whose administrative capacity surpassed that of his Roman contemporaries. Augustine lauded him as “the Catholic bishop and Catholic martyr,” and Vincent of Lérins called him “the light of all saints, martyrs, and bishops.” His temperament reflected the Petrine firmness more than Pauline dialectic or Johannine mysticism.

His true sphere was not speculative theology—where he lacked originality—but ecclesiastical governance and discipline. In defending Church unity, he resisted schismatics, even when this meant tacitly opposing his teacher Tertullian. Yet his stance was not rigidly submissive to Rome: in the rebaptism controversy, he upheld African independence with the aphorisms, “Custom without truth is antiquity of error” and “We must not be ruled by custom but conquered by reason.”

Though accused of pride, his high view of the episcopate sprang from a profound sense of divine vocation and accountability. Collegial in counsel, compassionate toward widows, orphans, and the poor, he combined authority with gentleness. During the plague of 252 he ministered fearlessly to friend and foe alike. His earlier withdrawal during the Decian persecution—undertaken, he said, at divine prompting—was criticized as cowardice, but his martyrdom erased all doubt of his courage.

Moral Discipline and Personal Life

Cyprian’s moral teaching was severe: he forbade ostentation in women’s dress, opposed all contact with pagan entertainments, and rejected compromises with worldliness. His personal life was ascetic, marked by a readiness for death and a longing for the eternal homeland, eloquently expressed in De Mortalitate. For him, the heavenly city was the realm of true peace, where apostles, prophets, martyrs, virgins, and the merciful await their reward in Christ’s presence.

Writings and Legacy

Cyprian’s literary gifts were rhetorical rather than original, excelling in clarity, balance, and persuasive force. His works fall chiefly into three groups:

1. Ecclesiastical Governance and Discipline
Chief among these is De Unitate Ecclesiae (251), the “great charter” of Catholic high-churchmanship. His eighty-one surviving letters, addressed to bishops, clergy, laity, confessors, and the lapsed, form a vivid chronicle of mid-third-century church life. De Lapsis (250) condemns lax penitential discipline.

2. Moral Treatises
These include De Gratia Dei (246), De Oratione Dominica (252), De Mortalitate (252), De Habitu Virginum, Ad Martyrium, De Opere et Eleemosynis (254–256), De Bono Patientiae, and De Zelo et Livore (c. 256). They range from ascetic exhortations to appeals for charity, all imbued with pastoral earnestness.

3. Apologetic Works
De Idolorum Vanitate and Testimonia adversus Judaeos reflect his formative years, drawing heavily on Tertullian and Minucius Felix, assembling biblical proofs for Christ’s messiahship and divinity.

Among pseudo-Cyprianic works is Adversus Aleatores, a condemnation of gambling likely authored by Pope Victor (190–202), recently reattributed by Harnack.

In Cyprian, the ancient Catholic conception of episcopal authority—simultaneously collegial and hierarchical—found one of its most forceful exponents. His thought has been invoked both in support of and in opposition to the papacy, his name a touchstone in the enduring dialogue over the Church’s unity and governance.

This entry was posted in 2. Ante-Nicene (101-325 AD). Bookmark the permalink.

Comments are closed.